Treasure Trove II vs Nantucket II Swing Set: Which Fits Your Yard?
By Outdoor Playsets | Backyard Swing Sets | Published: 2026-10-28
Category: Comparisons
Compare the massive Treasure Trove II and classic Nantucket II swing sets. We break down size, features, and budget to help you choose the right fit for your backyard.
Quick Answer
Choose the Treasure Trove II if you have a large yard and want a feature-packed playset with multiple decks and slides. Choose the Nantucket II if you prefer a classic, charming wooden set that fits smaller spaces and budgets.
Size and Capacity: The Biggest Difference
The Treasure Trove II is a massive swing set with two covered play decks, a clatter bridge, a tower, and three slides. It's designed to entertain multiple kids with plenty of room to explore. The Nantucket II is more compact, offering classic fun with a real wood roof, decorative chimney, and working shutters, plus an Alpine Wave Slide™ and climbing wall.
If your yard is on the smaller side or you have just one or two kids, the Nantucket II provides a charming, functional playset without overwhelming the space. For larger families or frequent playdates, the Treasure Trove II's multiple decks and slides keep more kids engaged at once.
Budget and Value
Price is a major factor. The Nantucket II is significantly more affordable, with a catalog price of $1,446.48 (compare at $2,009.00), making it an accessible option for many families. The Treasure Trove II is a premium investment at $5,191.16 (compare at $7,748.00), reflecting its larger footprint and extensive features.
Think about how much use the set will get and how long you plan to stay in your home. If you want a long-term, feature-rich playset that can handle a crowd, the Treasure Trove II justifies its higher price. If you're looking for a quality set that fits a tighter budget, the Nantucket II delivers classic fun without the premium cost.
Trade-Offs to Consider
- Yard space: Measure your available space. The Treasure Trove II needs a large, open area; the Nantucket II fits better in modest backyards. Use a tape measure to confirm clearance before you order.
- Number of kids: If you have multiple children or frequent playdates, the Treasure Trove II's multiple decks and slides keep everyone busy. For one or two kids, the Nantucket II is plenty. Consider your typical playgroup size.
- Budget: The Nantucket II is a budget-friendly choice at around $1,446. The Treasure Trove II is a premium investment at around $5,191. Decide what fits your wallet without sacrificing must-have features. Set a budget range before you compare final options.
- Installation: Both sets offer an add-on installation option. The Treasure Trove II's larger size may require more time and effort to assemble, even with professional help. Factor installation costs into your total budget.
Product Facts
- Treasure Trove II Swing Set: Massive swing set with two covered play decks, a clatter bridge and tower, and three action-packed slides. This means the Treasure Trove II offers a huge variety of play areas, ideal for keeping multiple kids entertained for hours.
Treasure Trove II Swing Set - Nantucket II Swing Set: Classic backyard fun with a real wood roof, decorative chimney, working shutters, Alpine Wave Slide™, climbing wall, and multiple swing stations. The Nantucket II brings charming details and essential activities in a more compact design, perfect for smaller yards or budget-conscious families.
Nantucket II Swing Set
Which One Should You Choose?
Best For
- Families with large yards who want a feature-packed playset for multiple kids
- Those who want a long-term investment with a variety of play activities
Not For
- Smaller yards or tight spaces
- Budget-conscious shoppers who prefer a more affordable option
